A Claude comment on this article: https://meanjin.com.au/essays/the-case-for-china-or-a-self-obituary/

By Ouyang Yu

This is a profound and deeply personal essay by Ouyang Yu that explores themes of migration, cultural alienation, and the experience of being a Chinese-Australian writer. It's structured as a fragmented "self-obituary," using the recurring character 死 (death) as a divider between sections.

Key Themes and Observations:

Structural Innovation: The essay uses a collage-like structure, weaving together memories, dialogues, literary references, and philosophical reflections. The recurring death character suggests both the literal deaths of characters and the metaphorical death the author feels living as a perpetual outsider in Australia.

Systematic Exclusion: Ouyang documents what he perceives as structural racism in Australian cultural institutions. His friend Potato Flower predicts Chinese Australians "will write us books but will never be allowed to win the Miles Franklin Award, add something to the arts but will never be allowed to win the Archibald Prize." The essay chronicles decades of rejected job applications and manuscripts, suggesting a face that functions as "a death sentence" in Australian academia and publishing.

The "Caste" Framework: Drawing on Isabel Wilkerson's concept of caste, Ouyang argues Australia operates with invisible but rigid hierarchies that keep Chinese Australians permanently marginalized, regardless of qualifications or contributions.

Geopolitical Tensions: The essay engages directly with Australia-China relations, particularly during the Morrison era. Ouyang questions the logic of "countering China's rise" while simultaneously depending on Chinese markets. The final section removed by "self-censorship" suggests the constraints on speaking freely about these tensions.

Comparative Alienation: Ouyang acknowledges he faced discrimination in China due to his father's class status, but argues nothing compares to "a face sentenced to life imprisonment, academically and economically, in a second country."

Literary Resilience: Despite rejection, the poet continues creating—becoming a self-publisher, translator, and champion of works that exist outside official channels. The essay celebrates those who create without recognition or commercial success.

The essay is both an indictment of Australian multiculturalism's limitations and a meditation on the costs of diaspora. It's raw, angry, melancholic, and deeply literary—refusing easy consolations while insisting on bearing witness to experiences typically rendered invisible.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

002, from Poetry Remarks

By Ouyang Yu
Image
Mel C. Thompson Publishing, San Francisco, 2013, p. 23. [I said 'no page number' because my lower ear mark concealed it, my apologies. Then I thought: What a fantastic idea if there's no page numbers! I have a book that has no Contents although it timidly carries page numbers. See Two Hearts, Two Tongues and Rain-coloured Eyes . Wild Peony, 2002. In future, I'd make a poetry book with no Contents and no page numbers. Why make things so easy for people that they won't even bother reading?] This book is long out of print, so don't start thinking that I'm trying to promote something. I've only got one copy in the world and I'm not selling it.
Read more

LOWER DOWNS, RUBBISH AND LOW POETRY by Ouyang Yu

By Ouyang Yu
Beauty is so far from being the dominant principle of modern poetry that many of the most splendid modern works are clearly portrayals of ugliness - Friedrich Schlegel ( On the Study of Greek Poetry , 1797) Contemporary Chinese poetry has unashamedly turned from the sublime and sacred to the vulgar and profane. In April 1999 at the Panfeng Conference in Pinggu County, Beijing, poets split into two camps, the  zhishi fenzi  (intellectual) and the  minjian . 1  The poets in the intellectual camp (Wang Jiaxin, Ouyang Jianghe, Xi Chuan, Zang Di and others) were mostly well-published, anthologised, critically acclaimed, well-travelled and internationally well-connected. As university professor and poetry critic Cheng Guangwei noted, much of their poetry reflects the influences of Western literary masters such as Yeats, Rilke, Lowell, Pound, Baudelaire, Milosz, Pasternak and Brodsky. 2  The  minjian camp (Yu Jian, Yi Sha, Xu Jiang and others) critiqued these infl...
Read more

Self Publishing, a poem by Ouyang Yu

By Ouyang Yu
In a way, everything is self publishing. When you open your mouth to talk, you are self publishing because you don’t want someone else to speak for you even if he or she were the speech writer for Howard or Bush or Mao Zedong. When the rain decides to fall it is self publishing, on a regional scale, sometimes on a statewide scale. You can’t dismiss it as unworthily self publishing because it doesn’t fall on a national scale or international scale. Rivers in the world are self publishing on a daily and nightly basis. Even a little creek is self publishing when it winds its way through an industrial zone clogged with toxicity and waste. Birds never remain quiet because they don’t get paid for calling, their ways of self publishing that never is actually recorded in human history, not even in birds’ history, and when sometimes it does get recorded as in relaxation music they still don’t get paid and they still keep singing, their ways of self publishing. Some great self publish...
Read more